Farmers' and Oregon Trollers' meetings Oct 21 at the Merrill Center with Congressman Greg Walden, Oregon Governor candidate Ron Saxton, Senator Doug Whitsett Oregon District 28, Klamath County Commissioner Bill Brown, coastal trollers and Klamath irrigators-30 people.
Greg Addington complimented farmer Dick Carleton and Oregon troller Bob Kemp for leading the discussion to form an alliance. He said that the meeting this summer with Oregon Senator Smith and NOAA representative led to agreement on solutions: Long Lake water storage and hatcheries. Hatcheries were put there 40-50 years ago and are included in the 2002 NAS report; the blueprint for restoration. He said we have a four cabinet agreement to get the NAS recommendations happening. He also stressed the need to involve resource users in decisions regarding solutions.
Boley said the fisheries disaster in 2006 was not their making or the farmers', but the fishers were singled out as the solution. He said they need direct assistance for disaster relief. Ocean management needs to be more responsive. They need DNA checks for the salmon. 1/2 the disaster relief funds should go to the fishers, and the rest for solutions for farmers, fishermen and tribes. He said fishermen and farmers have common ground and they can fix the problems. "We need cold water storage; there are fixes."
The Klamath Water Users met 37 times and made a workable plan for a water bank in 2002, explained Whitsett, and the federal government ignored it. The feds created their own water bank which is not working. He recommended hatchery management to be considered..
Dan Keppen, former KWUA Executive Director and current director of Family Farm Alliance, said he fears the funds might all go to NOAA fisheries. He feels funds should go directly for relief to support fishermen and not to the government to spend.
Walden asked the Oregon trollers, "Does Glen Spain from PCFFA represent you," and they all responded at once, "No." They said they didn't know of anyone that he represented in Oregon and do not agree with his tactics. "There are people who want to shut down ag, fishing and timber," added Walden.
Besides filing lawsuits against the irrigators, Spain previously wrote letters to the Oregon trollers to create an adversarial opinion of Klamath irrigators. Go HERE for letter from Spain to Oregon trollers: Spain: "...the leadership of the Klamath Water User's Association (KWUA) do not care about fish -- they care about making sure they have all the irrigation water they want, and the fish be damned. The current closed door efforts of the KWUA to "woo" certain salmon trollers on the Oregon coast to their cause is one example of how they hope to use fishermen for their purposes. ..."
Addington said the reason he thought fishermen didn't like the irrigators was because of PCFFA and their lawsuits; he thought PCFFA represented them.
Walden said of the federal government, "Their goal posts keep moving." They have put millions of dollars into Klamath Basin conservation measures.
Boley said Iron Gate is not being managed successfully; parasites are held there. It needs to be fine tuned. We could use mini hatcheries and have more science on genetics. The Stepp program is a salmon and trout enhancement program. It can produce 3 1/2 million fish per year using all volunteer labor and donations. "In our local groups there are altogether 300 people who would volunteer." Since naturally spawned fish are genetically identical with hatchery-spawned fish, hatcheries can succeed with the right fish stock .
He said one fisherman hatched salmon in his bath tub but DFG shut him down. If they had gotten into the creek DFG would have arrested him.
Coastal fisherman James L Moore, previously a Klamath farmer and KWUA director, said they had people do restoration, the Stepp program, and actively ran hatcheries, and there were enough fish. In 1989 NOAA fisheries shifted ideology and ODFW restricted how many hatchery fish could be released. There are people willing to put hatch boxes on their property, but they can't because ODFW wants to control hatchery production. "If it isn't the Klamath, it will be another river" that the feds will use to shut down the fisheries using weak stock management.
Fisherman Reeves said that the feds won't let them run the hatcheries because they have no biology degree. Congressman Walden responded, "I've seen biologists with degrees who have made bad decisions."
A fisherman said there are more fish in the ocean now yet the government is regulating one run of salmon on the Klamath. Sacramento had the largest run in history but the feds would not allow the fishermen to fish it because they might catch a Klamath Chinook that was not spawned in a hatchery because of a low estimated run.
Saxton said he appreciated the opportunity to be at the meeting. He said the state does have a large role and he looks forward to working with Congressman Walden if he is elected governor.
Walden said the fishermen need disaster assistance and 'ground up' approaches by stakeholders to find solutions for farmers and fish. He said management must adapt to different needs rather than single stock management.
Boley said that agencies are not stakeholders. He said trollers don't want a political agenda which is dam removal. He said they want real solutions, real water and real fish.
Carleton said the fishermen want real time monitoring of the river and cold water storage; if they don't store cold water there will be none.
A fisherman said that they are beneficial food producers and their needs should be addressed on the farm bill.
Commissioner Brown stressed that miners need to be part of this coalition also.
There will be more meetings with farmers and fishermen. Their problems are not finding solutions to the problems; they know how to find solutions. Their challenge is to get the federal government to allow them, the stakeholders, to act on those solutions and keep their industries and ecosystems productive and healthy.
NOTE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, any copyrighted
material herein is distributed without profit or payment to those who have
expressed a prior interest in receiving this information for non-profit
research and educational purposes only. For more information go to: